EMR standards
Status: proposed EMR standards, awaiting gemological and commercial validation.
1. Vision and objectives
Emerald Market Reports (EMR) is developing a standardised system to classify, compare, value and track the prices of natural emeralds, primarily from Muzo, Colombia.
The long-term goal is a data infrastructure and reference indexes usable for:
- Objective evaluation of emeralds
- Aggregation of international prices
- Comparison of stones of equivalent quality
- Publication of per-carat price indexes
- Historical analysis of prices and liquidity
- Standardisation of physical transactions
- Vault custody
- Escrow-secured transactions
- Physical deposit and redemption
- Eventually, an organised secondary market
Core principle: two emeralds with comparable gemological characteristics may belong to the same EMR category without having identical value or being automatically interchangeable.
2. Proposed benchmarks
EMR starts with two reference categories: Commercial and Premium.
| Characteristic | Commercial benchmark | Premium benchmark |
|---|---|---|
| Benchmark ID | EMR-C100 | EMR-P350 |
| Gemstone | Natural emerald | Natural emerald |
| Origin | Muzo, Colombia | Muzo, Colombia |
| Weight | 1.00 ± 0.05 ct | 3.50 ± 0.10 ct |
| Eligible weight | 0.95–1.05 ct | 3.40–3.60 ct |
| Colour / tone | T3 | T3 |
| Clarity | C4 | C4 |
| Brilliance | B3 | B3 |
| Treatment | F1 | F1 |
| Cut | Emerald step cut | Emerald step cut |
| Shape | Rectangular octagonal | Rectangular octagonal |
| Transparency | Transparent | Transparent |
| Saturation | Strong / vivid | Strong / vivid |
| Target market | Commercial | Premium |
| Purpose | Higher-volume trading | Premium trading |
| Price | Target CAD $1,300 / stone | Market-derived |
| Certification | Independent gemological report | Independent gemological report |
Both benchmarks have exactly the same colour, clarity and brilliance grades. The main difference is weight. The commercial benchmark is a more accessible stone, not necessarily a lower-quality one.
CAD $1,300 for EMR-C100 is a commercial target to be tested with suppliers, not a confirmed market price. Regular availability at that price remains to be demonstrated.
3. Classification system
Three independent scales: T1–T6 colour/tone, C1–C6 clarity, B1–B6 brilliance — developed from an emerald-specific visual reference and organised along Munsell colour principles. They are not grades officially recognised by GIA, SSEF or Gübelin. See the Grading page for each scale.
Colour must be evaluated under standardised lighting with calibrated photography and, ideally, physical master stones. The printed or digital chart is a comparison tool, not a substitute for physical and instrumental expertise.
4. Detailed gemological standard
4.1 Mineral identification
- Species: natural beryl
- Variety: emerald
- Formula: Be₃Al₂Si₆O₁₈
- Natural origin: mandatory
- Synthetic material: excluded
- Composite material: excluded
- Mounted stones: excluded from the primary benchmark
4.2 Provenance
- Country: Colombia
- Mining region: Muzo, Boyacá
- Origin certificate: required
- Mine traceability: required for confirmed Muzo status
- Country-origin confidence and mine-origin confidence: documented separately
A laboratory's Colombian-origin opinion is not automatically proof of the Muzo mine.
4.3 Cut and proportions
- Shape: rectangular octagonal
- Cut: emerald step cut
- Length/width ratio: 1.30–1.50 (proposed)
- Symmetry and polish: very good / excellent
- Windowing and extinction: minimal
- Facet alignment: regular
- Girdle: structurally sound; culet intact
- Chips: none; repairs: none
Recorded per stone: length, width and depth (mm), table %, total depth %, length/width ratio, girdle thickness. Tolerances will be validated on a representative set of traded stones.
5. Treatment — F1
Both benchmarks require F1 — minor clarity enhancement — with documentation of: enhancement level, filler material when identifiable, stability, treating laboratory and report date. Colourless oil is preferred; artificial colouring and undisclosed treatment are not accepted.
Possible fillers to identify: cedarwood oil, other natural oils, synthetic oils, natural resins, synthetic resins, polymers, dyed fillers and other fracture fillers. Verification uses microscopy, FTIR, Raman and other laboratory methods.
6. Equipment and procedures
| Area | Instruments |
|---|---|
| Colour | D65 viewing cabinet · Munsell colour book · emerald master stones · spectrophotometer UV-Vis-NIR · colorimeter (CIELAB) · calibrated camera and macro lens · colour calibration card |
| Clarity | 10× triplet loupe · binocular gem microscope 10×–60× · darkfield illumination · fibre-optic light · inclusion reference atlas · microscope camera |
| Brilliance | Standardised viewing cabinet · controlled lighting · macro photography · proportion analysis · windowing and extinction inspection · brilliance master set B1–B6 |
| Measurements | Carat scale (0.001 ct) · digital gem caliper · proportion analyser · 3D gem scanner (optional) |
| Treatment & origin | FTIR · Raman · UV-Vis-NIR · refractometer · polariscope · dichroscope · UV lamp 365/254 nm · trace-element analysis LA-ICP-MS (external lab) · independent laboratory report · mine provenance documents |
Minimum EMR starter kit
- D65 viewing cabinet
- Munsell colour book
- Reference emerald master stones
- 10× triplet loupe
- Gem microscope 10×–60×
- Fibre-optic light
- Digital carat scale
- Digital caliper
- Macro camera with colour calibration
- Digital grading database
- Independent laboratory certification
No single instrument guarantees T3, C4 or B3. Grades must be calibrated with physical stones and an observation protocol. F1 and filler identification require laboratory expertise; Muzo origin cannot be proven with a loupe.
7. Market pricing system
Every price record should include: stone ID, benchmark ID, origin, carat weight, T/C/B grades, treatment grade and material, laboratory and report number, source name and URL/document, listing and transaction dates, original currency, price per carat, total price, channel (wholesale/retail/auction), bid, ask, executed price, taxes/fees/commissions and a data-confidence level.
| Price type | Definition |
|---|---|
| Observed transactions | Sales actually concluded, with sufficient evidence |
| Firm bids / offers | Executable price commitments under documented conditions |
| Asking prices | Amounts requested by sellers |
| Expert valuations | Professional estimates, not necessarily transaction prices |
These categories are never mixed without distinction.
8. Index architecture
| Indicator | What it measures | Inputs |
|---|---|---|
| EQS — Emerald Quality Score | Gemological quality, 0–100 | Colour/tone, hue, saturation, clarity, transparency, brilliance, cut, treatment, structural integrity |
| EMV — Emerald Market Value | Fair market value of each stone | USD/ct estimate, total value, wholesale and retail ranges, fast-liquidation estimate, comparables, confidence interval |
| ELI — Emerald Liquidity Index | Ease of resale | Bid–ask spread, time to sell, transaction frequency, market depth, buyers and sellers, inventory and turnover, executable dealer bids |
ELI is independent from EQS: a gemologically excellent stone can still be hard to resell quickly. Weightings will be set after validation by gemologists and analysis of market data.
9. Weight choice
| Weight | Intended role |
|---|---|
| 1.00 ± 0.05 ct | Commercial benchmark |
| 3.00 ± 0.10 ct | Alternative core price index |
| 3.50 ± 0.10 ct | Premium benchmark |
| 4.00 ± 0.10 ct | Alternative premium reference |
Stones near 1 ct likely reach a wider market thanks to a lower ticket. The 3–5 ct range matters for higher-quality emeralds, but public data does not show 3.50 ct to be systematically more liquid than 3.00 or 4.00 ct. The current choice must be validated with executed prices, availability and dealer buy-back commitments.
Per-carat price depends on weight, quality and rarity: total price does not scale linearly with weight, so the premium price is never derived by multiplying the 1 ct price.
10. Why emerald weights carry more decimals
- No rigid rounding standard: unlike grid-priced diamonds, coloured stones vary widely in saturation, inclusions and proportions. Labs and dealers often list the exact scale reading — often to three decimals — so buyers know the true weight.
- Cutters prioritise weight retention: emerald rough is irregular and prone to inclusions, so stones are shaped to keep weight and colour rather than to reach round-number carat thresholds.
11. Transaction documents
| Code | Document | Function |
|---|---|---|
| SPA | Sale & Purchase Agreement | Contract of sale |
| GIA / SSEF / GRS / Gübelin | Gemological report | Identity, treatments, origin where determinable |
| COO / C/O | Certificate of Origin | Commercial provenance |
| CI | Commercial Invoice | Invoice |
| PL | Packing List | List of goods shipped |
| EA | Escrow Agreement | Escrow, if used |
| WR / VR | Warehouse / Vault Receipt | Deposit receipt, if stored |
| IC | Insurance Certificate | Insurance |
| DO | Delivery Order | Release instruction |
| AWB | Air Waybill | Air transport document |
| TTA | Title Transfer Agreement | Transfer of ownership |
| KYC / AML | Know Your Customer / Anti-Money Laundering | Compliance, per jurisdiction |
| KP | Kimberley Process Certificate | Rough diamonds only |
There is no universal standard for emeralds equivalent to LBMA Good Delivery. Acronyms are not all universal and legal effect depends on jurisdiction.
12. What commodity markets use
| Market | Standard / document | Function |
|---|---|---|
| Gold | LBMA Good Delivery Rules | Eligible bars: fineness, weight, marks, accredited refiner |
| Gold | COMEX gold futures specifications | Deliverable bars to settle a contract |
| Gold | COMEX depository rules / warehouse receipts | Storage, warrants and delivery |
| Copper | LME Copper Grade A specifications | Eligible copper, typically 99.99% purity |
| Copper | LME warehouse warrants | Electronic title to a lot stored in an approved warehouse |
| Oil | NYMEX WTI specifications | Deliverable quality and delivery terms |
| Oil | Certificates of quality / quantity · bill of lading | Cargo quality, quantity and title |
| Diamonds | GIA diamond grading report | Identification and grading |
| Emeralds | GIA coloured stone identification & origin report | Identification, origin where determinable, treatment |
Metals and oil have contracts that make certain qualities interchangeable. Gemstones have gemological reports, but generally no universal delivery standard that lets them trade as a homogeneous commodity. GIA identifies and describes emeralds but does not assign a universal quality grade.
Diamond Standard has explored grouping different diamonds into physical units designed to have a standardised value, with certification data, regulated custody and digital receipts — a conceptual precedent for emeralds, though not proof that a liquid secondary market exists.
13. Good delivery, custody and redemption
| Proposed document | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Emerald Good Delivery Standard (EGDS) | Defines stones eligible for deposit |
| Emerald Contract Specifications | Tradable unit, weights, quality categories, tolerances, delivery obligations |
| Emerald Identification & Treatment Report | Authenticates the stone, its treatments and characteristics |
| Emerald Vault Receipt (EVR) | Evidences the deposit of an identified stone |
| Emerald Ownership Registry | Tracks rights and transfers |
| Emerald Physical Redemption Rules | Withdrawal, fees and delays |
| Emerald Price Index Methodology | Data and calculation of the index |
| Deliverable Grade & Substitution Rules | Whether another stone may satisfy a delivery obligation |
Proposed names for this project, not recognised international standards.
The standard is built on four levels: Identity (natural stone, unique ID, certification, treatments), Quality (weight, colour, transparency, clarity, cut, origin), Custody (physical deposit, audit, insurance, traceability) and Delivery (withdrawal, transfer of title, substitution, dispute resolution).
Two redemption mechanisms must be distinguished: withdrawal of the exact stone deposited, and withdrawal of an equivalent stone of the same standard grade. The first is much simpler; the second needs a real equivalence method, reserves, value-adjustment rules and legal analysis.
14. Eligibility classes
| Class | Definition |
|---|---|
| Exact match | Matches the nominal benchmark: origin, weight, grades, treatment and cut |
| Deliverable grade | Within EMR's official delivery tolerances |
| Comparable grade | Differences adjustable by a valuation model, not automatically deliverable |
For physical deposits, each stone keeps its individual identity and traceability. Substitution is never presumed equivalent simply because two stones share an EMR grade.
15. Identification and traceability
Each stone has a unique EMR Stone ID with: benchmark classification, weight, dimensions, T/C/B grade, treatment, provenance, laboratory report number and date, front, back and microscope photography, physical condition, custody location, ownership record, chain of custody, insurance and inspection history. Any change in treatment, repair or damage triggers a new evaluation before deposit, sale or withdrawal.
16. Quality control and scientific validation
- Build a collection of physical reference stones
- Fix a lighting and photography protocol
- Define each T, C and B grade objectively
- Test repeatability
- Have the same stones graded by several independent gemologists
- Measure disagreement between graders
- Adjust classifications where needed
- Test price models on independent transactions
- Publish methods, limits and uncertainty criteria
- Review the standards periodically
The current visual charts are classification prototypes, not validated scientific certificates.
17. Open questions before launch
- Can exact Muzo provenance be documented reliably for each stone?
- Are T3, C4 and B3 reproducible across gemologists?
- Do the proposed physical parameters fit the stones actually available?
- Is there regular supply of EMR-C100 stones near CAD $1,300?
- How many stones matching each benchmark actually sell per month?
- What firm buy-back prices will dealers commit to?
- Are bid–ask spreads compatible with a secondary market?
- Can delivery tolerances be set without excessive value differences?
- Which certifications and guarantees should accompany each deposit?
- Which legal rules govern deposit receipts, ownership and physical withdrawal?
Central question for gemologists: can an 'Emerald Good Delivery' standard — comparable to LBMA Good Delivery for gold — make two different emeralds economically equivalent and interchangeable for deposit, trading and physical withdrawal? If so, with which characteristics, tolerances and certification methods?